ADS
Gen Z: 51% Think College Was a Waste of Money
In the past, college degrees were seen as the key to success in the job market. However, recent studies have shown that the importance of a college degree is diminishing. According to a study conducted by the Indeed Hiring Lab, employer demand for college degrees is declining. Additionally, a poll of 772 U.S. professionals with associate degrees or higher revealed that there is a growing sentiment among workers that higher education may not provide the return on investment that was once expected.
The poll found that Generation Z is the most skeptical about the value of their college degrees. In fact, a staggering 51% of Gen Z respondents believe that their degrees were a waste of money. This is in stark contrast to only 20% of Baby Boomers who shared the same sentiment. The shift in attitudes towards college degrees can be attributed to several factors.
ADS
One of the main reasons for this shift is the changing economic landscape. While college degrees traditionally led to higher earning potential, the so-called “college wage premium” has plateaued in recent years. This means that the financial benefits of obtaining a college degree are not as significant as they once were. At the same time, the cost of college education has skyrocketed. Inflation-adjusted tuition and fees have increased by 32% to 45% over the past two decades, making it even more difficult for graduates to see a positive return on their investment.
Furthermore, many college graduates are burdened with student loans that can hinder their career advancement. More than half (52%) of the survey respondents reported graduating with school debt, with Millennials being the most affected. For 58% of Millennials, student loans have delayed their career progression more than their degree itself. Additionally, those with student debt are more likely to believe that their degrees were a waste of money compared to those without debt.
ADS
Another factor contributing to the skepticism towards college degrees is the oversaturation of the job market with degree holders. Sociologist Jonathan Horowitz explains that when college degrees become more common, there may not be enough high-skilled jobs to accommodate all graduates, leading some to be pushed into lower-skilled roles. This oversupply of college graduates can diminish the perceived value of a degree.
Despite these challenges, most college graduates still recognize the value of the skills they have acquired. However, a growing number of them believe that they could perform their current roles without their degrees. This sentiment is particularly prevalent among younger generations, with 68% of Gen Z respondents feeling that their degrees are not essential to their current jobs.
Moreover, the changing job market has seen a shift in the hiring requirements of employers. As of January 2024, 52% of job posts on Indeed no longer specify the need for formal education, up from 49% in 2019. This indicates that companies are beginning to view high school and college graduates as interchangeable. Despite this trend, the majority of survey respondents would still be upset if their peers were able to attain similar positions without a degree.
The cognitive dissonance experienced by degree holders reflects the frustration of investing time and money in their education, only to find that their competitive advantage has diminished. This shift in perception towards college degrees has significant implications for the future of higher education.
While there are concerns about the diminishing returns on college degrees, some individuals still see value in education beyond technical skills. For example, Nico Maggioli, a communications design graduate from Syracuse University, believes that his degree was worth it for the creative thinking skills he acquired. Maggioli emphasizes the importance of developing a designer’s perspective rather than focusing solely on technical details, especially in a world where AI is increasingly capable of performing technical tasks.
As the workplace continues to evolve with the advancement of AI technology, educational institutions must adapt to ensure that students are equipped with the necessary skills for success. Francisco Marmolejo, a Higher Education Advisor, emphasizes the importance of teaching essential skills such as analytical thinking, teamwork, and critical thinking in preparation for an AI-driven world. By focusing on these “soft skills,” schools can better prepare students for the rapidly changing job market.
In conclusion, the changing perceptions towards college degrees among Gen Z and other generations highlight the need for a reevaluation of the value of higher education. While there are concerns about the return on investment and oversaturation of the job market with degree holders, there is still value in the skills and perspectives that college education can provide. As the job market continues to evolve, it is essential for educational institutions to adapt to ensure that students are equipped with the skills needed to succeed in the future.
